'The Cat Burglar, Part 2' - gay sex story @ Menonthenet.com's Gay Erotic Stories

Menonthenet.com Gay Erotic Stories. Last updated May 20, 2018 - Home of 21259 erotic stories

Your Cookies are not enabled. You will not be able to register or login to your profile.

The Cat Burglar, Part 2

By Creative Cat

submitted September 8, 1997

Categories: Exotic

Text Size:

The Cat Burglar, Part II

Part 2

by Creativecat@hotmail.com

Scott was definitely excited about Thursday night's possibilities - he couldn't sleep all week because he had a huge boner every night that he had to beat down with his greasy hands. It wasn't enough to anticipate what would happen. Larry was filled in on what would happen - Darren, the head of the fraternity and Phil, the guy who was "rushing" him into the fraternity were to come with him around midnight when all would be quiet. Everything went as planned. Larry was tiptoeing in a similar outfit as usual. The two other preppies were similarly dressed. Except it didn't look as good with their blonde hair and clear blue eyes. Darren and Phil could almost pass off as twins with their wholesome good looks and nicely formed bodies.

"Let me go in first," Larry said. "I know the way around the house." He sure did know is way around the house. He, too, was so horny during the week that he had to sneak over on Tuesday night and have a quick fling with Scott. Scott was a considerate lover who reciprocated with everything. Although Larry had never fucked a guy before, he had never felt so good in his life. He also admired Scott for being fair with him. Larry, too, was excited about what occur tonight and he had trouble sleeping the night before as well as concentrating on his class work all day.

As Larry went from the sun room to the living room, Scott "jumped" into action and grabbed Larry by the throat. Larry was actually startled by the move and let out a yelp. "Oh, no!" Larry exclaimed. The other two froze in the back of the sun room. "I think he's got a gun and he's pointing it at you Darren. Don't do anything stupid!" Larry knew darned well he didn't have a gun, but it was quite effective in scaring the two of them.

"All right you three guys. What's going on? I don't want to shoot."

Darren and Phil were literally scared shitless. They wouldn't have noticed Larry's acting as they were quaking in their shoes. Larry did the talking. "Uh, um, we were returning some stuff we sort of borrowed the other night."

"Borrowed? I had some stuff stolen the other night," Scott replied.

"Sir - it was just a prank from my frat house. You see, I want to join and we were bringing back the stuff. We meant no harm."

"No harm? You call breaking and entering and upsetting my poor sick sister no harm?" Of course there was no sick sister, but it made the guys even more upset. "I have a strong mind to call the police. Or maybe I should teach you guys a lesson."

"A lesson. Oh, no, sir, please don't hurt us."

"I'm not going to hurt any of you. Go into the den over there. And strip off all your clothes."

"What?" Darren asked.

"Just what I said. Take off all your clothes and hand them to me. If I have your clothes, I think there's a chance you won't try to escape as a policeman might arrest you for indecent exposure. Except what I see over there is actually pretty decent." Darren and Phil looked pretty sheepish as they handed over their clothing. Larry was doing all he could to stop from getting an erection. Scott now had some ankle chains that he soon put on each guy.

"What's this you're doing?" Darren asked. Not as cocky as usual, but he was asking what was going on. He was scared.

"These are chains so you won't run away. They're anchored to that bracket in the floor so you guys won't be going anywhere for a while. They're from the chain gang when my uncle was the warden. I was going to use them in the garden around the posts, but these are proving pretty useful tonight. They don't hurt so don't panic. Just sit down on the couch while I think of what to do." He walked up to Darren and looked at him. In the soft light of the room, he couldn't believe how good looking he was. All three of them! They were in the perfect bloom of early adulthood when all looks perfect with a man. Not a blemish or mark on any of them - just visual perfection to look at their lean, tan, and muscular bodies. Flat stomachs, muscular thighs, strong arms, nice chests. They all had firm round nipples. They were all standing out in the cool evening air. "You're a good looking guy Darren. Wouldn't want anything to happen to that pretty body of yours, would you?"

"No. No, sir."

Scott was stroking Darren's shoulders ever so gently. Darren quivered in fright at first. He began to relax when he felt the warmth of Scott's caress. "Just relax kid. I'm still thinking of what to do to you. I'll bet you're the leader of this idea, aren't you?"

"No. No, I'm not."

"Don't lie to me, kid!" Scott raised his voice and his hand. "Just tell me the fucking truth or I'll slam you pretty darned hard!"

"All right, yes, it's my idea." He started to cry a little. This is where Scott wanted him. Actually where Larry wanted him. Darren was a cocky shit who thought he was so perfect. Well, Larry was going to have his way with him tonight!

"All right punk, turn over and kneel down. Spread those legs apart so I can see those nice ass cheeks of yours. You do look mighty nice that way." Scott's fingers were caressing and squeezing Darren's cheeks. He put one finger in his anus. Then a second and a third finger. "I'm going to have to get something else to use on you to put you into shape." He brought out a large 10" dildo. Okay, fellow, I want you to insert it up there. Put some nice goo on it so it'll slide right up there." Phil began to insert the dildo up Darren's ass. Darren started crying at first. He felt so humiliated, so dirty, so awful. "And don't cry to me kid. You're the one who started it tonight! Keep pumping that dildo kid." Scott couldn't contain the hard-on in his trousers anymore and started to undress. "I think you need the real thing up your ass kid. Now spread those cheeks really wide for me so you can feel it." Soon Scott was pumping his cock up and down inside Darren. Darren tried to fight it at first, but soon he relaxed when he realized the pleasure he was getting. His cock started going rigid.

"I'll bet you want that hot cock of yours sucked a little, don't you?" Come on over, you dildo-pumping guy. Come over and suck Darren's rigid cock. I can see you getting nice and hard and I know you want it down your throat." The chains were certainly long enough that they were able to comfortably move around the den. Phil started sucking tentatively on Darren's cock. Soon he was into the rhythmic action of pumping his head up and down on the rigid member. Larry was real turned on now by the site of these three guys having this illicit sex. He now was really hard and horny.

"Let me have my turn at Darren." Soon he was fucking his nice tight virgin ass. "Tell me how much you like it Darren. Isn't it great? I'll tell you, your ass feels better than any pussy I've had all year on campus!" His cock was going up and down that asshole - it felts so great and Darren was moaning as his asshole had become an incredible pleasure tunnel. The probing of the dildo and the cocks up his ass was incredible! Phil was greedily sucking on Darren's cock and Scott was fucking Phil's eager anus and Darren was now sucking on Scott's rigid piece of meat.

They were all fucking and sucking each other in different positions. Then Scott leaned over and let Darren fuck his tight ass. Phil fucked Darren's hairy butt and Larry was pumping on Phil's tight anus! It was too much for the four of them - their loads were soon exploding all over each other's butts and chests. They collapsed on the floor in a sweaty heap.

Soon there were flashing lights outside. This was the "bonus" surprise that even Larry didn't even know about. "What's going on?" Darren asked

"I think it's the police" Scott replied. And sure enough, two handsome studly cops in their early 30's showed up - Cal and Roger. They were both body builders. Scott put on his shorts and brought them in. "Well, these are the perpetrators. I taught them a little lesson in hopes they would clean up their act."

"What kind of lesson" asked Cal. He had dirty blonde hair, a full mustache, and nice hairy muscular arms. The kind you know would match the rest of his body - nice and hairy and furry and masculine. The type of body that would make a man feel like a real man. A masculine man's man.

"Well, I had to do a little butt fucking with them to get them into line."

"Shit, you should've called me and I could've taken care of them for you. In fact, I think they need a bit more conditioning." As he was saying that, his shirt was coming off. Roger was now naked, sporting a huge erection. Cal's erection was even bigger. Cal's body didn't displease - it was nice and hairy and masculine. Roger was the opposite - very dark, very smooth skinned, but he too had a great muscular chest and taut nipples. Cal went over to Darren and planted a sloppy kiss on him. Darren didn't fight it and soon their tongues were down each other's throat and their rigid cocks were pressed against each other. Darren was fingering the fur on Cal's chest and tugging at the nipples. Cal was sucking ever so gently on Darren's nipples. He lifted up Darren and put him over his shoulders with his cock right towards his mouth. He began tonguing his rigid cock. Larry came up behind and started tonguing on Darren's asshole. His asshole was a tunnel of pleasure tonight - everything being done to it was great! The two of them brought off Darren to another thunderous orgasm. Then Larry started working on Cal. Cal lifted Larry's legs up and started fucking him real nice and slow and good. Larry was writhing with delight. Cal pumped Larry's tight asshole with incredible relish and soon was spitting his load up Larry's butt. At that moment, he leant over to suck down every drop of Larry's intense orgasm. He didn't want to miss one drop of that delicious jism.

Roger was doing Phil real good. Phil was down on his hands and knees while Roger shoved his cock up Phil's eager asshole. Phil was being held up by Roger's very strong arms which squeezed and rubbed his chest muscles. Roger had never had his nipples rubbed like this in his life! His cock was oozing a river of precum. Scott was now over with these two guys and he began fucking Roger's asshole. Scott had never fucked Roger up the butt before - Roger was always too scared of Scott's huge member, but Roger was taking it up there all right tonight. Probably because it was the most turned on he had ever been in his life!

The six of them continued fucking into the morning - nearly every combination was tried. The frat boys were tired and had never had their cocks sucked and fucked in such ways before. Scott's cop "friends" left soon after and the four of them fell asleep on the floor.

Darren was the first to wake up. "Oh, shit, man, I thought this was just a bad dream."

"A bad dream?" Scott said. "I think this is what you've been dreaming about having all your life."

"Yeah, I suppose you're right. I did have a lot of fun last night. When are you gonna let us go?"

"You can go anytime. Take a look. The chains are gone. I took them off while you were asleep this morning. Your clothes are in the corner. I think you've learned a lesson."

"Yeah. You're right. How can I pay you back?"

"Well, you could come in tomorrow night and 'break' in and we can see what happens. If you've got any other fraternity brothers, that might make it even more fun. What do you think?"

"Shit, man, you've got a deal!"

So, until graduation, the three of them came over at least twice a week for some heavy duty action. They also managed to bring over a good percentage of the fraternity brothers over. Even during homecoming over the years to come, they always had their "reunions." Plus they never broke the law again.

By Creativecat@hotmail.com

Displaying Page 1 - Records 1 to 30

More stories From Creative Cat

An Indecent Workout

Mar 16, 1998

Scott: Well, I was rushing out to the gym to work with my personal trainer. Adam is a good trainer and real popular. Plus I was running late and I didn't want to miss out on the session. When you're paying $75.00 an hour, you want the best bang for your buck. And I definitely got it on that workout. Unfortunately when I got to the gym, I discovered I left nearly all my... read more

Rick had the time of his life at the first workout and knew he had to do it again. Although he didn't expect anything to happen, when he got locked out of his locker, things took a turn for the better! RICK I had a great time with my new trainer and we had some great sex together. It was awesome the way the two of us got along and the orgasms we experienced were truly... read more

Rick has become a real stud and has a reputation as being one of the hottest lays in town! He needed a new and more erotic experience to heighten his pleasures. RICK I had a wonderful time two weeks ago at the health club. I couldn't believe that I allowed myself to have such public and lewd sex at the gym. I managed to get a few calls over the next couple of weeks and... read more

Rick has become an insatiable sex machine. He will do nearly anything to get laid. This escapade nearly lands him in jail! Will this stop him from future incidents? Stay tuned for more in this indecent saga. RICK After that even in the restaurant with my boss and his two stepsons, I didn't know I would ever top it. But we did manage to top it on the way back. The... read more

RICK After the incident two nights ago at the health club, I was a bit nervous when the owner called me at home that night. I guess he hadn't heard about happened and I was relieved. He said they were filming a tv commercial and asked if I'd participate. They needed a few photogenic guys and he thought I'd be willing to come over. I figured it'd be fun, I asked if I got paid... read more


Feb 28, 1999

Blake had moved to town a couple of years ago to take the teaching job. He was thrilled to get this job as they were few and far between for his area of “expertise” but it was something that he had always wanted to do. It was a small town in Wisconsin where the winters could be harsh but beautiful – the snow would sparkle and the ice on the lake was magnificent to look at. And... read more

Buying A Mattress

Jun 29, 1999

By creativecat@hotmail.com I never dreamt (literally) that getting a mattress for my room would be such a wonderful and invigorating experience. If I had known what would've happened, I would've been shopping a lot more. Well, it was a warm summer afternoon. And since I'm a reasonably good looking guy of about 29 years of age and trying to stay in shape, I've managed to wear out... read more

Class Reunion

Jul 21, 1997

Adam was getting ready for the high school reunion. 20 years. He couldn't believe. That pimply faced kid who watched The Brady Bunch so many years ago was now a mature adult on the verge of middle age. He certainly looked a lot better. No longer was he that wiry little nerd who got straight A's in all those "geek" classes. He was now handsome and was a successful owner of... read more

College Intern

May 08, 1998

I was sitting in my office trying to get caught up with the workload. The joys of working for a smaller company that is trying to compete in a global market place. Always a bit too much work to do and not enough time to do it in. Luckily, the job wasn't too bad. My boss was a half-way decent guy who tried to be understanding. Unfortunately, he was one of those rich preppy types ... read more

College Intern, Part 2

May 23, 1998

Ross was packing up in his room. I wanted so bad to go upstairs and help him pack and pack my cock up his butt again but with his parents in the house, I knew I had to play it safe. He had changed into some tennis shorts almost like mine. He looked so inviting in those shorts and I could see that he enjoyed the view he had of my legs and upper torso. My shorts had deep slits up... read more

Counseling The Counselor, Part I Counseling the Counselor By Creativecat@hotmail.com May 1986 I knew it was going to be a long hot summer ahead of me. I hadn't gotten all my work done for school and was itching to graduate and get on my with my life. Grad school had proven to be more expensive than I ever thought it would be. It was fun, but costly... read more

Daddy's Cure

Apr 24, 1998

Greg hadn't been feeling too well that morning and decided to stay home. It was very much unlike him to stay home, as he tended to have a "workaholic" personality and wanted perfection in his business as well as his life. As he was maturing he realized he wasn't always going to have it. The business was a success, but he felt a hollow victory in realizing this. This was part of the... read more

Family Resemblance

Nov 29, 1999

GREG As someone who has always stayed in shape, I always like to show off my body. Many times I just wear a long t-shirt. It goes down my thighs and actually covers my butt so I can get up in the middle of the night to use the bath and I won't look too indecent in case there are any overnight guests who happen to see me. It's also comfortable for lounging in. I... read more

Luke The Detective

Jan 03, 1998

"We're going to need some help on this case and only a few of you are special enough to be able to do it. It seems there is some prostitution and possibly some drugs down at the local strip club." The officers' eyes opened wide at the possibility. "Don't get to excited about this men. It's the local women's club with those male dancers. I need someone to become a dancer and... read more

Relief To The Itch

Feb 28, 1999

It was a real hot day and I had just come back from a 42 mile bike ride. It had started out nice, actually a bit overcast but when the sun came out, it seemed to turn all the clouds to a hot and humid steam. There were a lot of hills and little shade so my body felt the heat. Especially my butt, it was hot and sore. Sweat had poured down my back and had gone down my crack and I... read more

Jeff liked his buff body and liked any opportunity to reveal it in its entirety. Jeff was tall and a nice muscular build. He had a nice tan over most of his body. The only part that stayed white was where he wore his very skimpy bikinis. All that remained were his ass cheeks as a creamy white and a small triangle in front which was encased in his golden public hairs. His chest was ... read more

Jeff was finally satisfied for once and felt very contented with the wonderful experiences he had that day. Life was good, he thought as he drove home in the dusk. He truly enjoyed the hedonistic pleasures his body gave him in both showing it off and the mutual sexual satisfaction he had with his partners. Plus he was beginning to make so many new "friends" with his appealing good... read more

Senior Prom

May 29, 1998

Well, school was almost over and life would now be beginning for me. It was with mixed emotions we went to the prom. Senior year was absolutely the best for me. Beyond school and getting good grades - I was third in the class - I was excited about going off to college and seeing beyond that small coastal town I grew up in. Although we were a suburb of New York City, I found some... read more

Sons of a Preacher Man, Part I By Creativecat@hotmail.com Jeff's business was thriving a couple of years later. He was thrilled with the way things were going - although the business he had bought was established, it needed some finesse and polish to expand. And expand it did - his computer services company managed to quadruple in size in this period. Plus he... read more

Sons of a Preacher Man, Part II By Creativecat@hotmail.com Part 2 Jeff couldn't believe how hard he was and how eager he was to feel Scott's hot tongue all over him. Scott parted Jeff's muscular thighs wide apart and began licking out his asshole. Jeff started moaning loudly and with frantic desire for Scott. "Oh, fuck me, I need to feel you up my ass. Eat... read more

Sons of a Preacher Man, Part III Part 3 Jeff's tongue started working on those low hanging hairy nuts and began to stick his tongue up his man cunt. How he loved to suck out a man's asshole. There was a warm, sweet taste to his asshole which made it even more tantalizing. Hugh's cock went completely rigid like a steel rod when Jeff's tongue started eagerly... read more

Summer Camp Counselor

Sep 03, 1997

by Creativecat@hotmail.com The memories I have of summer camp are more than special. They helped teach me survival skills, the joy of the fresh air, my appreciation of all types of nature as well as giving me a future perspective of my future as a gay person. It all started about 17 years ago when I was a young teenager away at camp for the summer. The camp was up ... read more

Swimming Lessons

Nov 03, 1997

"Hold your legs straight!" I was swimming and didn't know who had said that. I thought the pool attendant was talking to someone else but since I was the only one there, I guess he was talking to me. "Huh?" I said as I was so absorbed in my swimming. I had just taken it up in an attempt to get myself into better shape. Not that I was that bad, but I needed some firming up... read more

The Birthday Surpise

Jul 21, 1997

written by creativecat@hotmail.com Greg decided to finally get in shape. He was pushing 30 and knew he had to look better. His appearance was unruly. His hair was a little too long, his clothes had no style, and his body - well, what could you say? It was a body - not fat, not skinny, just nondescript. Greg's boyish looks were starting to lose their charm and he knew he... read more

The Cat Burglar by CreativeCat@hotmail.com Scott woke up in the middle of the night hearing a commotion downstairs. Usually he was a heavy sleeper, but something that night kept him from sleeping. It was a warm, muggy night that hung deep in the air. A feeling of sensuality clung in the humid air around his body. Since it was so warm, he had foregone the usual... read more

The Golfer and the Caddy, Part I Andrew drove out to the club for a golf game. He was very happy to have finally been accepted at the country club. Although Andrew wasn't really stuck up, he did take a lot of pride in his career, appearances, and the accessories that went along with his success. And the country club was one of those accessories that he so loved! The... read more

Part 2 Andrew thought out his plan - simple yet brilliant. He would arrange to "catch" the two of them in the act and surprise them. Then he'd join in the fun! Their plan was for next Wed. night. Andrew knew his wife would still be away with the kids and he couldn't wait for all the fun to happen. He was so horny the following week it was all he could to keep his hands off... read more

The Golfer And The Caddy, Part III Part 3 Andrew couldn't get Jorge out of his mind. As much as he enjoyed Glenn (he had sex with him 4 times in the past week!), he kept lusting over Jorge. He knew he had to be careful, real careful. He didn't want to do anything to jeopardize his business so he managed to put Jorge out of his mind. He was surprised when Jorge... read more

The IRS Audit

Jul 28, 1997

by Creativecat@hotmail.com Derek Jackson was in his office with Roger DeLeo, the IRS agent. Derek was perspiring - he didn't know what was causing it - was it his nerves (he knew he did almost everything by the book), the warmth of the day, or was it just looking at Roger? Roger was not your typical looking geek IRS agent. He was a good looking guy - tall, young, sandy blonde... read more

The Job Interview The Job Interview by Creativecat@hotmail.com I wasn't too happy at my job and had faxed out a few resumes last Sunday night from home. The people where I worked were real jerks--not that I have a hard-on against stupid employers, but they did stuff that made the characters in the Dilbert comic strip look intelligent and inspired. I could go on and on... read more

Page 1 of 2